Tuesday, February 5, 2013

Is Isagenix a Cult? Let's look at the definition...

What is the difference between MLM Business Schemes and Cults?  Consider the following definition of cult.  The similarities between the words below and the reality of modern-day MLM Pyramid Schemes like Isagenix, Herbalife, and others is kinda spooky!

Definition of cult (n)

bing.com · Bing Dictionary
cult
[ kult ]
  1. religion: a system of religious or spiritual beliefs, especially an informal and transient belief system regarded by others as misguided, unorthodox, extremist, or false, and directed by a charismatic, authoritarian leader
  2. religious group: a group of people who share religious or spiritual beliefs, especially beliefs regarded by others as misguided, unorthodox, extremist, or false
  3. idolization of somebody or something: an extreme or excessive admiration for a person, philosophy of life, or activity



 
"...A usually nonscientific method or regimen claimed by its originator to have exclusive or exceptional power in curing a particular disease.
  1. Obsessive, especially faddish, devotion to or veneration for a person, principle, or thing.
  2. The object of such devotion.



 

Tuesday, January 29, 2013

is isagenix safe?

Before buying Isagenix you should know whether it is safe. 

The short answer based on our research is that there are many signs that Isagenix is not safe, or that Isagenix may not be safe depending on the circumstances of the person who is taking the supplements, what else they are eating etc.

It is also important to keep in mind that there is no clear evidence that Isagenix is helpful.  So even if you take it and you don't have stomach cramps, nausea, light-headedness, disorientation, or one of the myiad side effects people have reported, there is no reason to take the risk and spend a lot of money on a product with the track record of Isagenix.

It is important to keep in mind that anecdotal opinions from individuals do not in any way constute rational scientific evidence that the supplements actual provided a health benefit.  Most of the content online about Isagenix is made up of this kind of "testimony"...if you are scientifically literate, you will obviously not take that stuff seriously.


Unfortunately the short answer is that we don't know and there are reasons to be concerned.

More broadly, the nutritional supplement industry in general is very poorly regulated in the US.  This dates back to the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act of 1994, which severely limited the ability of the US to protect consumers from dangerous supplements.

As Stephen Barret PhD writes:

"Most people think that dietary supplements and herbs are closely regulated to ensure that they are safe, effective, and truthfully advertised. Nothing could be further from the truth. Although some aspects of marketing are regulated, the United States Congress has concluded that "informed" consumers need little government protection. This conclusion was embodied in the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act of 1994—commonly referred to as "DSHEA"—which severely limits the FDA's ability to regulate these products."


Friday, January 25, 2013

Isagenix Ingredients?

What is in Isagenix?  Oddly enough the company doesn't want to tell you.  Like many nutrional products sold via MLM tacts, you can't find out exactly what is in the products! 

For more on the problem of MLM nutritional supplements not being transparent about their ingredients, see this excellent post by Caitlin E. Cahill

All the company gives you is a bullet point list of what they want you to know...basically the alleged benefits.

Wednesday, January 16, 2013

Detox diets: Do they work? - MayoClinic.com

Isagenix, and many similar nutrional supplements sold via MLM, are based on the idea of the "Detox Diet."  But before we get ahead of ourselves, what is the state of current research on whether Detox Diets work?

One take is below, courtesy of leading hospital and wellness research organization, the Mayo Clinic:

Detox diets: Do they work? - MayoClinic.com

The reason it's hard to find info on the dark side of MLM online...

When I warn people about the risks and costs of the MLM industry, I often am asked a good but somewhat naive question:  "The reason it's hard to find info on the dark side of MLM online?"

The answer is that because MLM companies and their top distributors (who together are the only participants who benefit from these schemes) has a huge vested interest in minimimizing the availability and accessibility of criticism and negative information about their products.  And they go all-out to blanket the web with apparently positive information about their products, much of it disguised as first-person testimony or even-handed analysis....much of it mediocre and informative...anything to make it harder for people to find more important information on the cons, the risks, and often shady backgrounds of the founders of Multi Level Marketing companies.

In other words, MLM acolytes fan out accross the web to bury the important but negative truth about risks, waste, and other negative impacts with astroturf posts that that one. 

Here is one of thousands of examples....On a comment on this post on the false medical claims made by Isagenix, an unidentifiable reader calling herself Megan posts the following

"I’ve never done the cleanse, but was thinking about doing so after the holidays. I’m no medical expert, but I am entering into health care as a nurse in the near future and nutrition fascinates me. The hypothesis that neurological syndromes and food allergies are attributed to toxicity *has* been supported by research (see Dr. Theo Colhoun’s work). Differences have been shown between subjects who ingest foods laden with additives and pesticides in contrast with with subjects who eat whole, organic foods. The effects of taking in said toxins can range anywhere from developmentally delayed children to reproductively impaired adults. These statements have been supported by data and research.

I recently read about the various P450 enzymes and their role in detoxifying our bodies…Could pesticides and additives have an adverse effect on these enzymes? I would love to see the research, but my instincts after reading more into the subject say perhaps.  .... Isagenix at least supports people in making healthier choices…Kale instead of candy perhaps. You are what you eat, and heck, if Isagenix gets people to drink a nutritional shake vs eating a happy meal, I’m all for it."

Aww, shucks Megan....you seem appealingly positive but suspiciously armed with pro-Isagenix talking points.  In this case another reader calls her out, writing that "Even Stevie Wonder can see" that Megan is an Isagenix rep.

Thursday, January 10, 2013

Not again... another "Christian based" MLM gig ....

Heads up: another "Christian based" MLM gig .... is yet another thread about something I find incredibly ironic and sad.  Even thought MLM seems to contradict the teachings of Jesus as I understand them from the bible (e.g. though shalt not worthip false idols, though shalt not steal,....)....MLM programs seem to appeal so many evangelical christians...apparently the wrongness of bringing evangelical zeal to the sale of overpriced and sometimes dangerous junk to loved ones is overlooked....

I have to ask you again:  would Jesus have approved of Isagenix, Herbalife, or Multi-Level Marketing in general.  A sane and thoughtful person would probably say no....

Why doesn't Isagenix share ingredient list?

Wow, talk about a poorly regulated industry and an outrageous pyramid scheme all rold into one.  Like many nutrional products sold via MLM tacticss, you can't find out exactly what is in the products! 

The closes you get to "information' about what you are being urged to put into you body is a bullet point list of what they want you to know...basically the alleged benefits.  This is where the MLM evangelist...I mean salesperson...steps in to assure you that you must believe in it for anecdotal reasons they will recite with religious fervor.  Sounds pretty much like evangelical religion, only it's about making the founders of these shady companies rich...a real shame.

For more on the problem of MLM nutritional supplements not being transparent about their ingredients, see this excellent post by Caitlin E. Cahill